Luis W. Alvarez
physicist, University of California, Nobel laureate
What the files record
Luis W. Alvarez of the University of California was one of five members of the Scientific Advisory Panel on Unidentified Flying Objects, which met from 14 to 17 January 1953. The panel's membership list gave his field of competency as physics and radar. A 1971 Australian Department of Defence paper said the CIA Office of Scientific Intelligence convened the panel in Washington.
The panel's report of 17 January 1953 said the evidence showed no indication of a direct physical threat to national security. Alvarez signed it. He also signed the longer version, which recommended that agencies strip the objects of their special status. The same signed text was later copied into a 1967 Air Force committee file and a 1953 transmittal.
The CIA summary recorded two technical contributions. On radar signals from one station appearing on another station's screen, Alvarez suggested a "controlled jitter", in which an operator would slightly alter his station's pulse rate. Lloyd Berkner favored a doppler filter. Alvarez felt his solution was simpler and cheaper.
The summary also covered two cases of cosmic ray counters behaving oddly. For the Los Alamos observations, circuit diagrams and records were available. The summary said Alvarez pointed out that the data were due to instrumental effects. The panel rejected the idea that radioactive effects were tied to the objects.
What the files quote
“Dr. Alvarez felt such a technical solution was simpler and would cost much less than”
“Dr. Alvarez was able quickly to point out that the recorded data were undoubtedly due to instrumental effects”